"On 28 February 2027, the people will therefore have to vote on an amendment to the Nuclear Energy Act," says Jean-Yves Pidoux, the former director of the SILs and author of "Nucléaire: un improbable retour. Le débat suisse en perspective", a book available in December 2026.
"Several indicators show that the construction and energy sectors continue to be confronted with difficulties in terms of succession and recruitment," regrets Kornelia Hässig Vinzens, head of the Training and Professional Development Service in the energy field at the OFEN.
"A wind farm can be perceived with pride, as a contribution to our security of supply, a milestone toward greater autonomy," says René Longet, a member of the committee of the association ProEole Geneva and author of « Planète Etat d'urgence : Les réponses de la durabilité ».
For or against nuclear power? That is no longer the question
"In an energy context marked by significant uncertainties, can Switzerland afford to rule out certain sources of production from the outset?" asks Dominique Rochat, Energy & Infrastructure Project Manager at economiesuisse.
For those who did not experience them, Switzerland is today experiencing a rapid return to the 1980s. Parliament's approval of the counter-proposal to the "Blackout" initiative has brought back the "Nuclear? No thanks" stickers, revived arguments heard a thousand times, and put a new vote on the horizon after a referendum was launched.
However, we are in a completely different scenario than forty years ago, and it would be wrong to reduce this vote to a simple decision for or against nuclear power. The real issue lies elsewhere: it concerns Switzerland's security of supply.
The people's voice guaranteed
Let's first go back to 2017, at the vote on the Energy Act. Contrary to what is often heard, the people's yes did not ban nuclear power from Switzerland forever. Indeed, the full set of regulations governing the construction and operation of plants remains written into law.
But for a project to be realized, it would have to pass three stages. The Federal Council would first have to grant it a general authorization, subject to an optional referendum. Next would come the authorization to construct, then to operate, both of which could be subject to appeals.
At present, however, the government can no longer grant a general authorization, and it is precisely this lock that the counter-proposal removes. But the essential point remains: the people retain the final say on any potential power plant projects. Approving the counter-proposal therefore is not bringing back nuclear power, but reclaiming the right to choose.
Why would opponents of nuclear power fear a vote, when they would have no difficulty sinking a project with good arguments? The complete change in the energy landscape is probably part of the reason. Russia's aggression against Ukraine in 2022 brutally highlighted one reality: the security of electricity supply is not a given. It has even become a major strategic priority for Switzerland, whose ambition is to make electricity the main energy carrier in order to progressively replace fossil fuels and thus reach the goal of net-zero emissions.
Realizing such an ambition requires establishing a robust supply. This implies widely diversifying production, adapting networks, strengthening interconnection with our European neighbors, and moderating consumption, while keeping costs under control for end customers. To be honest, we are still a long way off.
A complex equation to solve
Switzerland faces an a priori rather simple equation to solve. The shift from fossil fuels to electricity will increase its consumption by at least a third. At the same time, nuclear production will disappear. Over the course of the year, it accounts for a quarter of total production, but its share reaches 40% in winter. The solution, therefore, is to develop new production capacity sufficiently and in time, focusing on winter.
Currently, we are turning this relatively simple problem into an equation with multiple unknowns. Admittedly, renewable electricity production is making clear progress, but not enough to reach the targeted goals. It is especially lacking in diversity, because its development is concentrated on photovoltaics, which is very productive in summer and much less in winter. Its winter complements, wind and hydropower, are developing very slowly, or not at all.
At this rate, the electricity deficit in winter can only widen, which will greatly increase our dependence on imports or the need to build gas-fired power plants, as the Germans are preparing to do.
In this context of great uncertainty, can Switzerland afford to rule out certain sources of production outright? Many European countries are asking the same question and are re-evaluating their position on nuclear power. Our parliamentarians have taken note of the evolution of the energy context and have chosen to strengthen supply security. Supporting their decision will not cause new nuclear power plants to spring up, but will place this option back among the possible solutions and hand the key to the Swiss people.
This article has been automatically translated using AI. If you notice any errors, please don't hesitate to contact us.
"All installations of transmission, railway power-supply and distribution networks with a voltage exceeding 1 kV will henceforth be of national interest," says Jan Flückiger, head of public affairs at AES.
"Initiatives like Swiss Impact & Prosperity show that, beyond growth, an economy's ability to create sustainable value and to preserve its resources is also becoming a performance indicator," explains Simone Pedrazzini, CEO of Earth Action.
"By constantly looking at the surfaces that could still accommodate solar installations, we may be overlooking one possibility: roofs that are already equipped," points out Alban Bitz, director of SI-REN.
"While it puts manufacturers under pressure, the fall in costs benefits project developers, electricity producers and suppliers, as well as consumers," explains Christian Rom, manager at DNB Asset Management.